Fairy tales were rescued from the nursery in the twentieth century when fantasy writers pointed out that originally, they were NOT intended for children or, rather, children alone. They were for children and adults and anyone else listening to the oral story teller.
The point here is that genre/topic does not determine that something is for children.
Neither does the age of the protagonist. To Kill A Mockingbird can be read by a range of ages--I read it when I was a teen--but the book is usually housed in the adult section, despite the narrator being a child for most of the story.
![]() |
| To explore this topic, I |
| compared Enright's stories |
| for adults to her books for kids. |
And yet, I would suggest there is a difference between books for children and books for adults.
I guess that the difference lies in the "allusions" within a story.
Technically, a literary allusion is a reference in one text to another. A story that passingly references the Iliad or Latin is counting on the readers' familiarity with the Iliad (or Latin)--hopefully (one hopes the writer isn't simply showing off).
In the same way that a literary allusion depends on reader familiarity, a story's plot and characters also depend on a level of familiarity. It isn't that readers can't enjoy books from different time periods involving experiences the readers will never undertake themselves (like going into space or using magic).
But there is a need for readers to be able to relate. A book about divorce from a child's or teen's point of view is relatable to children, teens, and adults. But a book about divorce from an adult's point of view can be understood by a child or teen but isn't necessarily relatable. The issue isn't "has this happened to you?" but the emotional capacity and life experience that allows, say, a single woman to comprehend the pain of adultery or the pain of loss or the confusion over identity.
So, perhaps, the marketers are right! What divides one type of book from another is what the readers actually care about/what they look for in a story/what they want to read.


No comments:
Post a Comment