Fabienne Marsh: The Moralist of the Alphabet Streets has a great beginning. The first-person narrator’s voice is quite amusing, being sardonic and thoughtful. However, the voice wasn’t entirely believable to me. It turns out to be that of an eighteen-year-old. An element of the book’s plot is that she is an unusual eighteen-year-old. But I was still disconcerted since for about three pages, I thought she was a middle-aged mother. I’m not sure if the surprise here is good or bad.
Ngaio Marsh: I started reading Ngaio Marsh books in college. I would read a new paperback mystery whenever I had to fly home (I bought them at the college bookstore). I’ve read nearly all of them. I consider Christie and Sayers to be better writers and better observers of human nature (whatever the dust jackets say), but I have a nostalgic love of Marsh nonetheless. Alex Marshall: A Crown for Cold Silver is one of those saga tales. I quickly tire of this type of writing. I prefer a story that is well-told and hangs together (a story arc!) rather than a cast of thousands saga with multiple sub-plots. My reaction isn’t just due to time and interest. There is something satisfying at reading such a tale, something that makes my entire self go “Ahhhh.” Sagas don't produce that reaction in me.
Archibald Marshall: Written in 1912, The Squire’s Daughter immediately reminded me of Anthony Trollope. I later discovered that Marshall was considered a successor to Trollope. However, unlike Anthony Trollope, Archibald Marshall has fallen into obscurity (though he does have a book on the shelves at the Portland Public Library!). I suspect that despite his facility for description, he lacks the dry tone and human insight of Trollope. The first chapter of The Squire’s Daughter struck me as inviting but quite light-weight.
Paule Marshall: Amazing first chapter! The setting, protagonist, and possible conflict are deftly presented without extra weight or, for that matter, deliberate “artistic” indirectness. I may come back to The Fisher King.


No comments:
Post a Comment