And he isn't in the book!
In the Joan Hickson Miss Marple movie Nemesis, Lionel is Miss Marple's waffling nephew who show up in St. Mary Mead when he is at loose ends. He accompanies his aunt when she starts out on the pilgrimage/investigation set in motion by Jason Rafiel.
From a writing perspective, the change here is perfect--on the page, Miss Marple can think about her task and review her options. But absent a voiceover (and I generally side against voiceovers), a film requires conversation. As a physically strong man with an ironic sense of humor and complete willingness to follow his aunt's lead, Lionel (played by Peter Tilbury), makes a great companion. He also acts well opposite Joan Hickson since he carries a touch of camp about his mild persona.And he changes. The film is far more generous with all the male characters, including Mr. Rafiel's estranged son Michael. One of the most touching scenes is when Lionel takes the initiative (finally) to track down Michael and gently inform him of the investigation's conclusion.
The transformation is gently done--it doesn't distract from Miss Marple's work and triumph. As all good transformations should be, it is all show, no tell. Lionel doesn't become someone else. He remains Lionel, only a more grounded and experienced Lionel.
The extra character is equally lightly done. Overall, the film is quite faithful to the book.
Excellent writing!



No comments:
Post a Comment